TALES OF THE SHIRE × REVIEWS
All reviews of Tales of the Shire.
10 reviews from 46 writers across 64 total pieces.
TYPESORT
2 AUG 2025
1 piece
LL
Lottie Lynn Eurogamer·2 Aug 2025
Tales of the Shire review - lost potential trapped beneath a tedious life simulatorreview
2/5
at Eurogamer
29 JUL 2025
1 piece
JC
Jessica Cogswell GameSpot·29 Jul 2025
Tales Of The Shire Review - Concerning, And Also There Are Hobbitsreview
4/10
at GameSpot
28 JUL 2025
8 pieces
DM
Review
at Screen Rant
KF
Kacee Fay Destructoid·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire review – A cozy hobbit life that sparkles on the surface, but never digs deepreview
6/10
at Destructoid
JW
James Watson Push Square·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire: A Lord of the Rings Game - One Cosy Game to Bore Them Allreview
4/10
at Push Square
CL
Claire Lewis Polygon·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire falls short of the LOTR Animal Crossing promisereview
Review
at Polygon
CL
Christopher Livingston PC Gamer·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game reviewreview
67/100
at PC Gamer
KG
Kate Gray Nintendo Life·28 Jul 2025
Tales Of The Shire: A The Lord Of The Rings Game (Switch) - The Hobbit, Or "There It Crashed Again"review
4/10
at Nintendo Life
TN
4/10
at IGN
EJ
Emma Jane Betts GamesRadar+·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire review: "As a long-time Tolkien fan, I'm both pleasantly surprised and slightly frustrated at what should've been my dream Lord of the Rings game"review
3/5
at GamesRadar+