Review2025-07-28
Tales of the Shire review – A cozy hobbit life that sparkles on the surface, but never digs deep
Did this help you decide?
Be the first to weigh in
Kacee Fay's score
Attributed score at Destructoid. We do not aggregate.
6/10
Also covering
Other writers on Tales of
Also covering
Other writers on Tales of the Shire
Also covering
Other writers on Digs
Also covering
Other writers on Surface
Also covering
Other writers on The Hobbit
More from Kacee Fay
Other recent pieces
·15 Sept
Aniimo review – A charming creature-collecting adventure with a whole lot to lovereviewonAniimo
·17 Jun
Everything shown during Disney Dreamlight Valley’s June 2026 Summer ShowcasenewsonDisney Dreamlight Valley
·25 May
Paralives brings your favorite indie games to your Paras in unprecedented collabnewsonParalives
·20 May
Paralives early access impressions — The beginnings of the next great life simnewsonParalives
Other reviews of Tales of the Shire
Reviewed at other outlets
Each writer's score with full attribution. Scores shown in the format their outlet uses. We do not aggregate.
LL
Lottie Lynn Eurogamer·2 Aug 2025
Tales of the Shire review - lost potential trapped beneath a tedious life simulator
JC
Jessica Cogswell GameSpot·29 Jul 2025
Tales Of The Shire Review - Concerning, And Also There Are HobbitsCL
Claire Lewis Polygon·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire falls short of the LOTR Animal Crossing promiseEJ
Emma Jane Betts GamesRadar+·28 Jul 2025
Tales of the Shire review: "As a long-time Tolkien fan, I'm both pleasantly surprised and slightly frustrated at what should've been my dream Lord of the Rings game"KG
Kate Gray Nintendo Life·28 Jul 2025
Tales Of The Shire: A The Lord Of The Rings Game (Switch) - The Hobbit, Or "There It Crashed Again"Community
What readers think of this piece
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Log in to add a comment.