Review2019-05-08

Sea of Thieves’ new PvP mode is a great idea, with plenty of room to grow

CM
Cass Marshall Polygon
243 articlessince 2018Active
Read original article →
Did this help you decide?
Be the first to weigh in
Writer
Top genres
RPGFPSAdventure
View profile →
Sea of Thieves
GAMESubject
Sea of Thieves
Genres · simulation
Release · Mar 20, 2018
Developer · Rare
Xbox OnePCXbox Series X|SPS5
88 articles 59 writers 13 reviews
The Room
SERIESCompared
The Room
Active · 2012–2020
Latest · The Room VR: A Dark Matter
Top genres · adventure, puzzle, indie
231 articles 137 writers 5 games
Also mentionsRareRarecompanyXbox Game StudiosXbox Game Studioscompany
Also covering

Other writers on Sea of Thieves

All writers →
MW

Matt Wales

Eurogamer · 10 Jul
18
Pieces
JG

Jordan Gerblick

GamesRadar+ · 24 Feb
6
Pieces
KH

Kyle Hilliard

Game Informer · 4 Jul
5
Pieces
AM

Alec Meer

Eurogamer · 23 Mar
4
Pieces
WY

Wesley Yin-Poole

IGN · 19 Nov
3
Pieces
Also covering

Other writers on Sea of Thieves

All writers →
HW

Heather Wald

GamesRadar+ · 22 May
4
Pieces
SL

Sam Loveridge

GamesRadar+ · 22 May
4
Pieces
RM

Ryan McCaffrey

IGN · 19 Dec
4
Pieces
JG

Jasmine Gould-Wilson

GamesRadar+ · 22 May
3
Pieces
EB

Emma-Jane Betts

GamesRadar+ · 22 May
3
Pieces
Also covering

Other writers on The Room

All writers →
RL

Rick Lane

Eurogamer · 24 Jan
8
Pieces
JW

John Walker

Kotaku · 30 Oct
5
Pieces
SM

Sean Martin

PC Gamer · 24 Feb
5
Pieces
BR

Ben Reeves

25 Mar
5
Pieces
MW

Mark Warren

Rock Paper Shotgun · 31 Mar
4
Pieces
More from Cass Marshall

Other recent pieces

All by Cass Marshall →
·30 Apr 2025
Creepy Redneck Dinosaur Mansion 3 is as delightful as the name implies
reviewonCreepy Redneck Dinosaur Mansion 3
Creepy Redneck Dinosaur Mansion 3
·29 Apr 2025
This free game turns the Turing test on its head with a scary AI quiz
news
·29 Apr 2025
Helldivers 2 players finally stopped the planet-cracking Singularity
newsonHelldivers 2
Helldivers 2
·21 Apr 2025
Look Outside is an instant classic that balances body horror with compassion
newsonLook Outside
Look Outside
·18 Apr 2025
These horror games are set outside the US, and that’s infinitely more interesting
news
Other reviews of Sea of Thieves

Reviewed at other outlets

All reviews of Sea of Thieves →

Each writer's score with full attribution. Scores shown in the format their outlet uses. We do not aggregate.

PO
Pj O'Reilly Pure Xbox·15 Mar 2020
Sea Of Thieves - In Truly Ship-Shape Condition Two Years After Launch
Sea of Thieves
RM
Ryan McCaffrey IGN·19 Dec 2018
Xbox in 2018: The Year in Review
State of Decay 2
BT
Brandin Tyrrel IGN·28 Mar 2018
Sea of Thieves Review
Sea of Thieves
CD
Christian Donlan Eurogamer·27 Mar 2018
Sea of Thieves review - a Rare treasure
Sea of Thieves
PB
Peter Brown GameSpot·27 Mar 2018
Sea Of Thieves Review: Set Sail With Trepidation
Sea of Thieves
Community

What readers think of this piece

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Log in to add a comment.